If your manager cannot approve a raise alone, the most important reader of your case may be someone you never meet: a person in HR, finance or a pay committee with your manager's word and one forwarded page to go on. So the work is not a brave speech in a one-to-one. It is a case your manager can forward without rewriting, and a rehearsal that makes the ask sound like part of the conversation instead of a leap away from it.
The six steps below come with the checklists, the wording and a rehearsal prompt, so you can work straight from the page. They cover the raise in the job you already have, with a manager you will still see on Monday, not the new job offer most salary advice is about.
Most people never ask, and comfort is the reason they give
Pew Research Center asked 5,188 U.S. workers in February 2023 about the last time they were hired. Only 30 percent said they had asked for more than the first offer, 60 percent had not, and the rest could not remember. Of those who asked, 28 percent got what they asked for and another 38 percent got part of it, so about two thirds came away with more.
That survey covered job offers, not raises, so read it as a signal, not a forecast for your review. The telling number is the reason people stayed quiet: 38 percent of those who did not ask said they did not feel comfortable asking.
Comfort comes from preparation, and preparing for a deadline is something you already do at work every week.
1. Start with what the company wants, not with what you want
Treat the raise like any project with a deadline: research, stakeholders, evidence, a clear message, and a rehearsal before go-live. The research starts with the company. Read the strategy and the goals for next year, and if your company publishes leadership behaviours or performance definitions for each level, find the ones for yours.
Then connect each achievement to one of those goals, in the strategy's own words. The difference is plain on paper:
- Before: "I worked hard on the migration."
- After: "The migration cut onboarding time, which supports the growth target in our strategy."
Use one pattern for every line: what you did, the result you can show, and the goal it supports, quoted from the strategy. Those lines become the spine of the page your manager forwards.
2. Profile your manager, then find out who really decides
Your most important stakeholder is your manager, so write down what you already know about them. Answer these for yourself:
- Are they a hands-off visionary or a detail person? A detail person will look for the numbers; a visionary will look for the line about the goal.
- What keeps them up at night right now?
- Do they prefer a conversation, an email or a one-page summary?
- Which wins do they care about most? Those are the stories to tell.
- How much control do they have over pay? Some decide. Others only carry your request to HR or a committee.
If you run out of questions, ask an AI tool to generate more about a manager's style and pressures, then answer them yourself from what you have seen.
The last question changes the job. If your manager is the messenger, you are not persuading them, you are arming the messenger. Give them a case they can forward without rewriting: short, factual and tied to goals the committee already cares about. Senior readers want the bottom line first, and our article on framing difficult messages for senior leadership shows that structure applied to bad news.
3. Know your market, then choose a precise number
Research pay for your exact role, level and region, from more than one real source, such as published salary surveys and job adverts that state a range. Do not take figures from the AI itself. A chat tool can produce a confident salary number with no source behind it.
From those sources, note three points: the 25th percentile, the median and the 90th. Then mark where you sit today. If a guide uses the 75th percentile as the stretch point instead, that works too, as long as every source matches your role, level and region.
If you work across two fields, say delivery and data, or engineering and compliance, look at roles that combine them too. People with that combination are often paid above a single-discipline benchmark, so the combined role may be the fairer comparison.
Then choose your number, ambitious but credible. A 2023 study in PNAS of 26 million eBay negotiations found that lower opening offers from buyers pulled final prices down, but that an overly ambitious offer raised the risk of no deal at all. A pay review is not an eBay listing, and the trade-off has the same shape: an extreme ask can stall the whole conversation.
Make the number precise as well. In experiments by Columbia Business School researchers, people who received a precise first offer made smaller counteroffer adjustments than people who received a round one, and judged the precise offer-maker to be better informed. The school's own example was $5,015 rather than $5,000.
Give the precision a reason. A figure you calculated from your sources is precise because it was worked out, and if your manager asks where it came from, you can show them.
4. Document the work nobody counted
Goals reviews tend to miss the stretch work, so list it yourself:
- the months you covered a vacant role
- the emergency you absorbed
- the colleagues in other teams you mentored or guided
- the risk you fixed before it became a problem, such as a new regulation or a fragile system
Write each item with a date range and a consequence: what would have happened if you had not done it. "Covered the vacant team lead role from [start] to [end], so the release stayed on schedule" says more than "stepped up when needed". The consequence is the part a committee can read as value.
5. Frame it as a market adjustment, and script the objections
Now write the story in a version you can say in about a minute. It moves from your review results to the ask, and it frames the request as a market adjustment, not a merit raise: your role has moved, and your pay has not kept up. A merit raise argues about how well you did this year, while a market adjustment argues about what the role is worth now, and your evidence from step 3 is built for that second argument.
The one-minute version has four parts:
- Your review result, in one sentence.
- Two or three mapped wins from step 1, plus the strongest piece of stretch work.
- The market finding: where your pay sits against the median for the role.
- The ask: a market adjustment to your precise figure.
Then write down the objections you expect, and an answer to each based on evidence, not feelings. The objection is not the end of the conversation. It is the part you rehearse most.
| Objection you expect | Answer to prepare |
|---|---|
| "There is no budget." | Accept it, then move the conversation forward with the lines below. Do not argue with the budget. |
| "The timing is bad." | Ask when the right time is, and agree a date to come back to it. |
| "Policy caps increases." | Return to the market data: the case is about the rate for the role, not this year's merit. Ask whether market adjustments follow a separate route. |
If the answer is that there is no budget, these three lines keep the door open:
I understand. When does the next budget cycle open?
What would you need to see from me by then?
Can we put that, and a review date, in writing?
6. Rehearse with an AI that has been told to say no
Before the rehearsal, collect everything in one place. These documents are what make the practice realistic:
- company strategy and goals for next year
- performance or leadership definitions, if your company has them
- your goals and your last review
- your resume for the current role
- your achievements, and the problems you solved
- market pay data for your role and region
- the profile of your manager from step 2
Now give the AI your manager's profile, your evidence and your market numbers, and ask it to play your manager, difficult on purpose:
Play my manager in a pay review, using this profile.
I will ask for a market adjustment.
Push back the way they would: budget, timing, policy.
Stay in character, even when my argument is good.
After each of my answers, tell me what was weak.
The instruction to stay in character matters. In a 2025 study of 267 people preparing for workplace negotiations, including asking for a raise, an AI coach built on a negotiation framework produced the largest drop in fear of the three options tested, while generic ChatGPT, used without that structure, did not reduce it. In follow-up interviews, five of the 15 people interviewed said the coach was too "agreeable" and asked for stricter pushback.
So give the AI a role, a profile and rules, and tell it to keep pushing. Then practise the hardest ten seconds: the move from reviewing your goals to the financial ask, which is where most people fumble. Say it out loud until the transition feels natural, then run the whole conversation again and let the AI say no this time.
After each round, cut the corporate language. "Structural realignment of my compensation" becomes "my pay has fallen behind the market for this role". Direct and professional beats impressive, because your manager has to repeat it to someone else.
Walk in with the page, the number and the answers
You walk in with a one-page summary, a specific number, and answers you have already said out loud. If the answer is not yes today, you still leave with something: a date, a target, and a manager who can argue your case to the people you will never meet.
Start this week with the easiest step. Open your company's strategy for next year and write one line under each goal about something you did for it. That page is the first draft of the one your manager forwards.
If your next raise comes from a new job instead, that is a different negotiation, with an offer on the table rather than a review. How to Land the Job and Interview for Project Managers has a full section on negotiating salary when you are offered a new job.


